Critical Thinking Skills

In order to receive any benefits from using the Scientific Method, one must become a critical thinker. The data collected must be analyzed and interpreted to form valid conclusions. If these conclusions are lacking credibility, then the data collected is worthless. One thing scientists know is that data can be interpreted in many different ways, and some of these ways may not be totally correct. In the following exercise you will be exposed to several situations that will help develop your critical thinking skills.

What is Truth? Truth can either be objective (discovered) or subjective (created). Objective truth is the actual state of affairs about things. Subjective truth is based on people making their own truth, hoping that believing something will actually make it so. As scientists we must seek objective truth.

Read the following statements and place an "a" if you think the truth is objective, and a"b" if it is subjective. Be prepared to explain your choices.

_____ A tax consultant preparing your income tax.

_____ A laboratory researcher attempting to find a cure for cancer.

_____ A person drinking some poison thinking it is Pepsi Colatm and won't hurt him.

______ A person standing on the sea shore looking at the horizon, thinking the world is flat.

_____ A sports referee making a crucial call in a game.

Why is it important for scientists to be objective when it come to examining scientific data?

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

Fact or Opinion? Opinions are beliefs about reality. Unlike facts, they are open to question and analysis by critical thinking. Classify the following examples as either a fact or an opinion.

1. The New York Knicks were the NBA champions in 1999. Fact or Opinion

2. Camel's hair brushes are made of Siberian squirrel fur. Fact or Opinion

3. Eyewitness testimony is generally unreliable. Fact or Opinion

4. Stalin's oppression of the Russians was more brutal than Hitler's oppression of the German people. Fact or Opinion

Many times statements seem to be factual but need some kind of documentation. If the proof can be found the statement is not an opinion. Determine if the following statements are "a" clearly a fact, "b" possible fact , but not clear without documentation, or "c" an opinion.

_____ 1. Short, stocky men are more attractive than tall,thin men.

_____ 2. All religions share the same fundamental truths.

_____ 3. Darwin's theory of evolution continues to be controversial.

_____ 4. Most high school drop outs lack the intelligence to succeed.

_____ 5. Religious history is filled with examples of inhumanity committed in the name of God.

Look at the answers to the statements in the above exercise and do as follows:

For each that you classified "b" state one or more reliable sources that could be cited to support the statement.

For each that you classified "c" write questions that might be raised about the statement.

 

Evaluate Evidence: Many times the data we receive comes in the form of opinions. Opinions are not wrong just because they are opinions. It is important to evaluate the data that is used to support the opinion and make judgments from there.

In each of the following cases, the first statement states an opinion, and the second sentence states supporting evidence. Decide whether the evidence is the best supporting statement that can be offered. If the evidence is faulty, replace the evidence with some that would correctly support the opinion.

a). Your Honor, I believe I was justified in hitting my wife. She kept nagging me to get a job.

_______________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________

b). I did not sign that petition. The person who asked me to sign refused to support my proposal last year.

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

c). Drugs should be legalized. Enforcing the nation's drug laws has proved an impossible task.

________________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________

Characteristics of Critical Thinkers:

1. They ask questions.

2. Produce many ideas instead of a single answer.

3. Base their judgments on evidence.

4. Acknowledge complexity in issues. There is no simple answer to problems.

5. Intellectually independent, they reassess views when new evidence comes to light.

6. Concepts can be applied to a multitude of different subjects.

Using the 6 characteristics of a critical thinker, write about one of the following issues. Decide what you think about that issue and list the evidence for your view. Next seek other views and additional evidence. Then decide which view is most reasonable. Then write a paper of at least several paragraphs persuading the reader to accept your view.

a). Do you favor subjecting animals to painful experiments in order to find cures for disease?

b). Do you believe that atheists can be as moral as religious believers?

c). Do you think it is a good idea to abolish compulsory attendance laws in the nation's high schools?

d). Do you believe one can be a sincere Christian and believe in the theory of Evolution?

e). Would you favor a manditory prison term for first time DWI convictions?

f). Why is drug consumption in the United States the highest in the world?